A strained ACL involves overstretching the ligament fibers (Grade 1 or 2 sprain) while it remains mostly intact and functional, causing mild pain and swelling. A torn ACL (Grade 3 rupture) means the ligament is partially or completely severed, resulting in severe pain, instability, a "pop" sensation, and significant swelling.

How to tell if you strained an ACL?

At the time of the injury, a “pop” or “snap” can sometimes be felt or heard. The amount of pain experienced at the time of the injury is somewhat variable but can be quite severe. Typically, the person is unable to continue play or activity, and has the impression that a significant injury has occurred.

How to tell if it's a tear or strain?

A strain is an overstretching or minor tearing of muscle or tendon fibers, causing localized pain, stiffness, and swelling, while a tear is a more severe injury involving a significant rip or complete rupture of muscle, tendon, or ligament tissue, often with intense pain, a popping sound, significant swelling, and instability, requiring longer recovery and potentially physical therapy or surgery. Essentially, a tear is a severe strain or sprain.
 

What does a torn or sprained ACL feel like?

Many people hear a pop or feel a "popping" sensation in the knee when an ACL injury occurs. Your knee may swell, feel unstable and become too painful to bear weight.

Is a strain better than a tear?

However, a tear is more serious than a strain because it can put you out of commission for longer. What are the Symptoms? A tear usually comes with intense pain, severe inflammation, swelling and even bleeding at the injury site.

What are the Differences Between ACL And Meniscal Injuries? | Expert Physio Guide

How do you tell if a ligament is stretched or torn?

Overstretching a ligament can result in injury, which sometimes includes tearing. A ligament injury is sometimes indicated by a “popping” sound and can be very painful, often accompanied by swelling and bruising. This popping sound is usually heard when an ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) is torn.

Will a strained ACL heal?

Some knee ligaments, such as the medial collateral ligament (MCL), heal reliably without surgery. Some partially torn ACLs, particularly in children and adolescents, may also heal without surgery. However, a complete tear of the ACL rarely heals.

What are three signs of an ACL tear?

Common ACL tear symptoms include:

• Feeling or hearing a pop in the knee.
• Severe pain, instability, and swelling in your knee.
• Being unable to bend and move your knee either fully or partially.
• Inability to stand up and hold your weight.

Can you strain your ACL and not tear it?

Grade I ACL Sprain

This type of ACL sprain occurs when the fibers of the ligament are stretched, but a tear does not exist. For the most part, the knee will remain stable. Symptoms of a Grade I sprain include tenderness, swelling, moderate knee pain, and some limit to mobility.

Should I wear a brace for an ACL sprain?

Grade 1 and 2 ACL injuries are typically cared for with rest, a good quality soft sleeve brace and restrengthening activity programs. These ensure the surrounding muscles are supporting the joint to provide protection to your ligament whilst it is healing and starting to load the joint again with activities.

How long does ACL sprain pain last?

ACL sprains are minor injuries with little long-term damage to the ligament. Sprains usually heal in one to two weeks with rest, icing, and over-the-counter pain medication as recommended by your orthopedic specialist. Our specialists offer a complete exam and thorough diagnosis for any ACL-related pain or injury.

Is a strain worse than a sprain?

Sprains and strains are equally bad. Strains affect the tendons, while sprains affect the ligaments. Tendons and ligaments are both connective tissues that are graded in severity. Therefore, you can have a mild sprain or a severe strain, or vice versa.

Do xrays show torn ligaments?

X-rays do NOT show tendons, ligaments, nerves, cartilage or blood vessels. X-rays typically show bones and joints, and may, at times, show the absence of skin (e.g. infection).

Can ligaments stretch but not tear?

Grade 1 (Mild): Ligament fibers are overstretched but not torn. There is mild pain, swelling, and instability. Grade 2 (Moderate): Partial tearing of the ligament. This may cause moderate pain, swelling, and some joint instability.

How can I tell if it's a tear or strain?

You might notice pain, swelling, bruising, and difficulty using the affected joint. A strain, though, involves muscles or tendons. This injury occurs when these tissues are overstretched or torn, often from overuse or sudden movements. Symptoms of a strain include pain, muscle spasms, weakness, and swelling.

Can a strain turn into a tear?

Muscle strain or a "pulled muscle" is an injury that causes stretching of the muscle fibers and can lead to a partial or complete tear of a muscle.

What happens if a knee sprain goes untreated?

The dangers of ignoring a knee injury

In the case of ligament tears or severe cartilage damage, ignoring the problem can lead to permanent joint damage and increase the likelihood of developing osteoarthritis. This degenerative condition can severely impact your mobility and quality of life as you age.

How do I tell if my ACL is partially torn?

One of the most immediate signs of a partial ACL tear is pain in the knee. This pain can vary from a dull ache to sharp, intense discomfort, especially when you put weight on the affected leg. The pain might worsen with activities that involve pivoting or sudden stops.

What can you not do if your ACL is torn?

Reduced activities.

Without an ACL, the knee is unlikely to support aggressive landing, cutting and pivoting. Living with a torn ACL may mean limiting participation in sports, work and activities that cause the knee to swell, give way or feel unstable.

---