Tearing an ACL graft (retear) occurs in approximately 5% to 15% of cases, with higher risks (up to 20% or more) in young, active individuals participating in high-demand sports. While early rupture is rare, the risk increases with return to sports, particularly if rehabilitation is incomplete or due to technical surgical issues.

What happens if you tear your ACL graft?

ACL graft failure occurs when the tendon used to reconstruct one's torn ACL tears after ACL surgery. This setback can be very disheartening for both the patient and their orthopedic surgeon, as it often requires a redo ACL surgery to restore knee stability and function.

How difficult is it to damage a new ACL graft?

Re-tear risk with patellar tendon graft is significantly lower than hamstrings grafts(2). In a large cohort of high-risk young women undergoing ACL reconstruction, the risk of patellar tendon graft re-tear was around 1% while the risk of hamstrings graft re-tear was almost 8%(2).

How to know if an ACL graft is torn?

ACL graft failure is a serious but manageable complication of ACL surgery. Early recognition of symptoms such as knee instability, persistent pain, and swelling can help prevent further damage and guide appropriate treatment.

How fragile is an ACL graft?

Although only 10% of grafts fail, this is still a large number of cases. There can be many reasons for an ACL reconstruction failure. The most common reason for an ACL graft to fail is due to technical issues with the original surgery.

How can I avoid injuring my ACL graft?

Do ACL grafts grow back?

It is the strongest type of graft found in the body and is just as strong as a normal ACL. The other benefit is that the tendon will grow back after taking the tissue out to create the new ACL. This means that the patient will not have permanent strength loss due to the graft harvesting process.

How did Mark Zuckerberg tear his ACL?

Mark Zuckerberg tore his ACL during a sparring session while training for a competitive mixed martial arts (MMA) fight in late 2023, sustaining the non-contact injury from an awkward movement that involved twisting his planted leg, leading to surgery and delaying his planned fight.
 

How do you know if you retear an ACL graft?

It is critical to recognize ACL retear early! Patients who experience a failed ACL surgery often present with: Persistent knee instability or “giving way” during pivoting, cutting, or jumping. Recurrent pain or swelling, particularly after activity.

When is an ACL graft most vulnerable?

Shockingly, during the healing process, the ACL graft tissue gradually weakens with decreased structural properties and the graft is most vulnerable at 6-7 weeks after surgery and the graft never returns to its original strength at the time of implantation!

Did Tom Brady ever tear his ACL?

Yes, Tom Brady tore his ACL (anterior cruciate ligament) and MCL (medial collateral ligament) in his left knee during the first game of the 2008 NFL season against the Kansas City Chiefs, an injury that ended his season but from which he made a remarkable comeback, winning Comeback Player of the Year in 2009 and multiple more Super Bowls later in his career.

What is the danger zone for ACL graft?

The 'danger zone' is between 3 to 9 months. As the graft develops a new blood supply within the knee after surgical reconstruction, the new cells remodel the graft and it becomes stronger. By 9 months, the graft will look and function like a new ligament and should be strong enough to cope with a full return to sports.

Can you get ACL surgery twice?

For those who have symptoms or would like to continue participation in certain sports, revision ACL reconstruction is an option. This requires removing the re-injured ligament and replacing it with a new graft.

Can I damage my ACL graft?

Returning to sport within 9 months of ACL surgery puts you at a higher chance of tearing your ACL graft. Most people who retear their ACL grafts will have it occur within 24 months of returning to sport after their ACL reconstruction surgery.

How many years does an ACL graft last?

One of the most common concerns after ACL surgery is how long the graft will last. Most patients retain strong, functional grafts for decades, often for life. Failures tend to result from new injuries or technical complications during surgery, rather than simple wear and tear.

What is the most painful ACL graft?

1, 2 Still, the most commonly used autografts for ACL reconstruction are the bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and hamstring tendons (HT). There is some evidence to suggest that BPTB autografts produce more pain than HT autografts both in the immediate postoperative period as well as in the long term.

What does a torn ACL graft feel like?

A loose ACL graft may cause instability in the knee, leading to difficulty with activities like walking or climbing stairs. Patients may feel a sense of their knee "giving way" or experience pain during certain movements.

What causes ACL graft failure?

Failure can mean the graft has stretched or ruptured, that it was not properly positioned, or that it has not healed adequately. It may also refer to persistent instability, pain, or stiffness despite surgery. In some cases, failure is due to new trauma or re-injury.

Can you recover 100% after ACL surgery?

If you tear your ACL, you'll probably need surgery to repair it. Most people who tear their ACL make a full recovery and resume playing sports with no long-term consequences. The recovery time for a torn ACL is usually six to nine months.

What are the odds of reinjury after ACL surgery?

Investigators have reported reinjury rates following ACL surgery to range as high as 30-39%. This rate of reinjury results in as many as 4 in every 10 surgeries being attributed to reinjury. This level of reinjury following ACL surgery is unacceptable.

How do you know if a graft failed?

The warning signs of early dental bone graft failure include: persistent pain, extreme swelling, excessive bleeding and signs of infection (puss, foul smell). Signs of late dental bone graft failure include: gum recession, tooth or implant mobility, and persistent sinus issues.

Can an ACL graft come loose?

Conclusion: A slightly loose graft at 6 months after ACLR increased the risk of later ACL revision surgery and/or graft failure, reduced the length of the athlete's sports career, caused permanent increased anterior laxity, and led to an inferior Lysholm score.

Did Patrick Mahomes tore his ACL?

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes tore the ACL in his left knee against the Los Angeles Chargers on Dec. 14. The injury was caused by hyperextension.

What knee surgery has Joe Rogan had?

His initial ACL reconstruction on one knee was this very invasive procedure where you take a piece of the patellar tendon and you take a third of that with symbone on either side, sometimes one side which I do, it's a two-inch incision and then reroot it through the knee and and most of the pain from that operation ...

What knee injury did Kobe Bryant have?

It was later confirmed that Bryant had suffered a tibial plateau fracture in his left knee. Colorado knee specialist Robert LaPrade MD, PhD. has dedicated himself to educating others on injuries related to the knee.

---